Whats a Philly cheese-steak?

[Theben]

Having traveled thru Philly and eaten an 'authentic' philly chz-steak I admit to being woefully underimpressed.

[Cookie Monster]

Nah, Boston or NYC make the best cheese steak subs!

I've tried Jim Steaks on South St. in Philly and wasn't too impressed. Any decent places in the city to get a philly cheese steak hogie?

[Brundlefly]

Originally posted by Albert Speer
no really? what is it? I cook some steak and cheese, put it on a roll, and, by virtue of me being in philly, it's a philly cheese-steak. correct?

The best cheesteak in the Delaware Valley is in NJ. Gaetano's. In Willingboro, Burlington, and a couple of other locations I can't recall. No place in Philly or anywhere else can beat them.

[Sprayber]

Originally posted by Q Cubed
real philly cheesesteaks are made in philly.

kinda like chicago dogs, or chicago deep dish. you *can* have it in other places, but the aura of the city isn't embedded in the cuisine, so it doesn't taste as good.

I can do without the aura of Chicago thank you

[Imran Siddiqui]

Originally posted by Jac de Molay
Cheez Wiz?! Commie

A good one has american or swiss. Plus you have to have onions and bell peppers mixed in with the meat.

That's authentic.

Sorry, buddy. Authentic Philly Cheese Steak is made with Cheese Wiz.

http://www.hollyeats.com/Pats.htm

Pat Oliveri invented the cheesesteak back in 1930. Since then generations of South Philadelphians have been heading to the corner of 9th and Shunk and to Pat's for a "Steak Wit" and a cherry soda.

"Steak Wit" translates to a cheesesteak topped with Cheeze Wiz and Fried onions.

[Q Classic]

I can do without the aura of Chicago thank you

c'mon, how could you?

i went into one of those hot dog joints near lincoln park with a few of my friends; there was a very clear sign saying "NO SMOKING" in the front, and as we were waiting for our order, the guy went back, picked up his lit cigarrette, and started cookin'. a bit of ash fell into the fry fryer...



how could you turn that down?

[Brundlefly]

Originally posted by Imran Siddiqui


Sorry, buddy. Authentic Philly Cheese Steak is made with Cheese Wiz.

http://www.hollyeats.com/Pats.htm

Pat Oliveri invented the cheesesteak back in 1930. Since then generations of South Philadelphians have been heading to the corner of 9th and Shunk and to Pat's for a "Steak Wit" and a cherry soda.

"Steak Wit" translates to a cheesesteak topped with Cheeze Wiz and Fried onions.

Pat's Steaks are for tourists who want an "authentic" Philly cheesteak. I can name at least a half-dozen places inside the city and in the suburbs that are better.

Pat's Steaks

Jim's Steaks

Gaetano's #1

[Imran Siddiqui]

Pat's Steaks are for tourists who want an "authentic" Philly cheesteak. I can name at least a half-dozen places inside the city and in the suburbs that are better.

'Better' doesn't matter worth a damn when you are talking about authentic. Cheese Wiz is a primary part of an authentic 'Philly Cheese Steak'.

[Brundlefly]

Originally posted by Imran Siddiqui

Quote:

Pat's Steaks are for tourists who want an "authentic" Philly cheesteak. I can name at least a half-dozen places inside the city and in the suburbs that are better.

'Better' doesn't matter worth a damn when you are talking about authentic. Cheese Wiz is a primary part of an authentic 'Philly Cheese Steak'.

I disagree. Pat's makes the "authentic" Philly CS because everyone accepts the claim that he invented CS in 1930. One of the ways you can have your authentic CS at Pats is with Cheese Wiz. A Philly CS does not become any less authentic w/o cheese whiz...

For those of you who have never had the benefit of enjoying a true Philadelphia Cheesesteak I offer the following classification guidelines for the proper manufacture and consumption of the "Philly Cheesesteak."

In Philly there are only three four things you can EXPECT to find in, surrounding or on a Cheesesteak and that is:

Hoagie Roll: Amoroso's is the most famous local bakery and is utilized by a few discerning Cheesteak vendors across the country. Despite the typical philadelphian's attitude towards the roll, there are a few suitable replacements worldwide; however, they are extremely difficult to find.

Steak: Thinly sliced meat: NOT Roast beef and not Steak-um (although Steak-um is the only acceptable replacement under extreme circumstances that allows you to continu to call it a Cheesesteak)

Cheese: (Provolone or White American Cheese) some people get Mozzarella, muenster, Jack or even Cheese Whiz but these are generally eschewed by true Philadelphians unless part of a specific adaptation such as The Pizza Steak.

Fried Onions: they are optional although sometimes automatically added and fried into the meat until soft and semi transparent. I believe the culinary term is "Carmelized"

[Imran Siddiqui]

A Philly CS does not become any less authentic w/o cheese whiz...

Yes it does . It is generally accepted that an authentic Philly Cheese Steak has Cheese Wiz on it. Just because they use new stuff now, doesn't mean the authentic version has changed. Just because New York and Chicago make better pizza, doesn't mean the authentic Italian pizza (very, very thin crust, little sauce and cheese) isn't authentic anymore.

[monolith94]

I like my cheese steaks with onions, peppers, great cheese, great meat, etc.

When they all come together, just right, it's a delightful sandwhich.

[Al B. Sure!]

Feephi knows too much

and david... larry bird was the center for the celtics back in the 80's and had a big rivalry with magic.

[Drake Tungsten]

Best outside-shooting center in history!

[Imran Siddiqui]

larry bird was the center for the celtics back in the 80's

Center?! Has someone never heard of Robert Parish? And I don't even really care about basketball.

Drake:

[Al B. Sure!]

i was born in 85 remember... this is all before my time... i got to say though that i can understand how yall feel. 12 year olds these days deny Jordan. thats just blasphemy for people my age.

[Imran Siddiqui]

i was born in 85 remember... this is all before my time

So? I was born in 80, that doesn't mean that I have no idea who Walter Payton and Jack Lambert are!

[Al B. Sure!]

i know who he is. tall white guy with bushy blonde hair.

[Tuberski]

Originally posted by Dissident
next thing he will say is he doesn't know who Dr. J is.

actually he probably doesn't know that. He's too young, or I'm too old.

Get to know your town Speer. You live in a city with a history. Unlike myself. My city is less than 100 years old. It really has no history. Just an old railroad town.

Philly has a very vibrant history- esp. in the 18th century.

Your town, Diss had a place across Las Vegas Blvd. called Rocky's(I believe), it had the best Philly Cheese steak I ever had, and IIRC, Imran it also used Cheez Wiz.

Had pictures of a lot of celebrities on the walls.

If it is still there it's somewhere between The Venetian and Casino Royale.

On further inquiry, it is at 7400 S. Las Vegas Blvd. It has obviously been moved off of "The Strip"

ACK!

[Drake Tungsten]

i was born in 85 remember...

I was born in 80

Damn, I wasn't even born in the same decade as you two. I feel so old...

[Imran Siddiqui]

HAW HAW!

[Tuberski]

I was born two decades and 12 years before Imran.



ACK!

[Drake Tungsten]

You can be my brother in agedness, Deathtongue.

[Tuberski]

We are the inbetweeners, between the Ming, rah, Slowwhand senior citizens group, and the Imran, Albert, young whippersnappers group.



ACK!

[Imran Siddiqui]

But yer still old!

[Tuberski]

Originally posted by Imran Siddiqui
But yer still old!

I'm not old, ask my wife, as she says, "I'm finally mature......"



ACK!

[Imran Siddiqui]

You may be older than Sloww even .

[Tuberski]

Now your getting personal.........



ACK!

[Imran Siddiqui]

I thought I had gotten personal before .

[Tuberski]

You did, but the last one was just rude!



ACK!