Thread Tools
Old December 17, 2003, 12:51   #31
CerberusIV
lifer
C4WDG United Dungeon DwellersC4BtSDG Templars
Emperor
 
CerberusIV's Avatar
 
Local Time: 15:46
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: on the Emerald Isle
Posts: 5,316
I don't see it as either tasteless or insensitive.

How many people died in the firebombing of Tokyo? In Japanese labour camps?

Weapons kill people because other people choose, or are forced, to use them. EG is just a piece of metal. Should we close all museums that display guns, military aircraft, tanks, warships, etc? I don't think so. Pretending these weapons never existed isn't helpful.

We should stop apologising, or expecting others to apologise, for wars and atrocities ordered by people long dead. But then it is harder to face current issues than argue over the past.
__________________
Never give an AI an even break.
CerberusIV is offline  
Old December 17, 2003, 12:53   #32
Winston
Emperor
 
Local Time: 16:46
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: Mar 1999
Posts: 6,291
The most tasteless and insensitive museum exhibit ever?

I guess that would be V.I. Lenin's mummified corpse on permanent display in a glass coffin for ahistoric lefties to worship.

But maybe that's just me.
Winston is offline  
Old December 17, 2003, 13:01   #33
Tripledoc
ACDG The Human Hive
Chieftain
 
Local Time: 14:46
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: Jan 2003
Posts: 55
Quote:
Originally posted by Winston
The most tasteless and insensitive museum exhibit ever?

I guess that would be V.I. Lenin's mummified corpse on permanent display in a glass coffin for ahistoric lefties to worship.

But maybe that's just me.
I've seen Lenin's Mausoleum and I don't think it was tasteless. I thought it was done rather well.
Tripledoc is offline  
Old December 17, 2003, 13:04   #34
Winston
Emperor
 
Local Time: 16:46
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: Mar 1999
Posts: 6,291
Quote:
Originally posted by Tripledoc


I've seen Lenin's Mausoleum and I don't think it was tasteless. I thought it was done rather well.
Of course you didn't think it was tasteless, since you didn't give his countless victims one single thought while you were there.

That's what I meant when I said ahistoric lefties, you see.
Winston is offline  
Old December 17, 2003, 13:08   #35
Tripledoc
ACDG The Human Hive
Chieftain
 
Local Time: 14:46
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: Jan 2003
Posts: 55
Quote:
Originally posted by Winston
Of course you didn't think it was tasteless, since you didn't give his countless victims one single thought while you were there.
How exactly do you know that. Are you a mindreader?
Tripledoc is offline  
Old December 17, 2003, 13:12   #36
DinoDoc
Civilization II Democracy GameApolytoners Hall of Fame
Deity
 
DinoDoc's Avatar
 
Local Time: 09:46
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: Sep 1999
Location: Underwater no one can hear sharks scream
Posts: 11,096
Quote:
Originally posted by CerberusIV
We should stop apologising, or expecting others to apologise, for wars and atrocities ordered by people long dead. But then it is harder to face current issues than argue over the past.

Quote:
How exactly do you know that. Are you a mindreader?
Your posts.
DinoDoc is offline  
Old December 17, 2003, 13:23   #37
JimmyCracksCorn
Chieftain
 
Local Time: 14:46
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: Dec 2002
Location: St. John's, Newfoundland
Posts: 48
Quote:
Originally posted by Agathon


I agree and while that may be disturbing, it's not such a big deal. This is like the Brits displaying a Lancaster and noting that it was used over Dresden without further comment, or the Japanese showing off an artillery piece that was used at Nangking.

Hiroshima is the supreme horror of the modern age, to soften it in any way is akin to denying the holocaust - whatever one thinks of the rightness of the attack.
Death is death, dude. It doesn't really matter how you die, just so long as you're dead.
JimmyCracksCorn is offline  
Old December 17, 2003, 13:27   #38
DinoDoc
Civilization II Democracy GameApolytoners Hall of Fame
Deity
 
DinoDoc's Avatar
 
Local Time: 09:46
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: Sep 1999
Location: Underwater no one can hear sharks scream
Posts: 11,096
God if you people really wish to ***** about something from WW2, pick Doolittle's raid on Tokyo. It was the closest we've ever come in launching a 9/11 style assault in both form and purpose.
__________________
Rosbifs are destructive scum- Spiffor
I make no bones about my moral support for [terrorist] organizations. - chegitz guevara
If government is big enough to give you everything you want, it is also big enough to take everything you have. - Gerald Ford
Blackwidow24 and FemmeAdonis fan club
DinoDoc is offline  
Old December 17, 2003, 13:29   #39
Cruddy
Warlord
 
Cruddy's Avatar
 
Local Time: 15:46
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: Mar 2003
Posts: 217
Quote:
Originally posted by Agathon


I agree and while that may be disturbing, it's not such a big deal. This is like the Brits displaying a Lancaster and noting that it was used over Dresden without further comment, .
Pretty sure S for Sugar at Hendon was used on Dresden - so what?

Most of the fatalities there were accidental - we couldn't have predicted a firestorm.

Would you rather we forgot these events? It's hard to tell from your posts.
__________________
Some cry `Allah O Akbar` in the street. And some carry Allah in their heart.
"The CIA does nothing, says nothing, allows nothing, unless its own interests are served. They are the biggest assembly of liars and theives this country ever put under one roof and they are an abomination" Deputy COS (Intel) US Army 1981-84
Cruddy is offline  
Old December 17, 2003, 13:36   #40
lord of the mark
Deity
 
lord of the mark's Avatar
 
Local Time: 10:46
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: Dec 2000
Location: Virginia
Posts: 11,160
would it be good to put the Enola Gay in historical context - yes. But a large number of americans, probably the majority, would not consider simply discussing the Japanese vicitims to be a complete context. They would want some discussion of the entire war, including Japanese atrocities, the possible costs of an invasion of Japan, etc. To present the casualties at Hiroshima without that context would be seen by them as a unbalanced presentation. This is precisely the issue that came up when parts of the Enola Gay were previously displayed.

again, the majority of americans do not see this as analogous to Auschwitz. You may disagree, but there it is.


Also the air and space museum displays a number of warplanes, including German, British, etc. It does not discuss civilian victims in those cases, and most Americans would question making an exception for the Enola Gay. As was said above this is an air and space flight museum, not a general history museum.


Of course there you have a larger issue - this museum does glorify aviation, and implicitly air power. and as everyone know, airpower since 1943 and for the foreseeable future is an area of American dominance and a key component of American power. Unfortunately no discussion of the morality of strategic bombing is possible in a veil of ignorance from that fact.
__________________
"A person cannot approach the divine by reaching beyond the human. To become human, is what this individual person, has been created for.” Martin Buber
lord of the mark is offline  
Old December 17, 2003, 13:38   #41
lord of the mark
Deity
 
lord of the mark's Avatar
 
Local Time: 10:46
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: Dec 2000
Location: Virginia
Posts: 11,160
Quote:
Originally posted by Agathon



Hiroshima is the supreme horror of the modern age,
with all due respect im not sure everyone agrees with that statement.

Hiroshima in fact killed fewer people than the firebombing of Tokyo. There was a gradual coarsening of attitude toward civilian deaths on the part of the allies, that started in august 1939. The notion of setting apart Hiroshima is largely due to 2 facts
1. The later construction of larger nuclear weapons capable of destroying all human life - something not entirely foreseeable in 1945.
2. The fact that making Hiroshima, rather than Auschwitz, or the Gulag, the supreme horror of the modern age fitted well with the ideological agendas of certain people during the cold war.
__________________
"A person cannot approach the divine by reaching beyond the human. To become human, is what this individual person, has been created for.” Martin Buber
lord of the mark is offline  
Old December 17, 2003, 13:38   #42
David Floyd
Emperor
 
Local Time: 14:46
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: Dec 1969
Location: The bottom of a large bottle of beer
Posts: 4,620
I oppose the atomic bombings (and the entire war) as much as anybody, but I fail to see how displaying a VERY FAMOUS historical artifact from the war is wrong. It may be insensitive to people who lived through the war, but then again no one forces them to look at it. Personally, I'd definitely go see the Enola Gay - I was disappointed at having missed it at the National Air and Space Museum a few years ago.
__________________
Follow me on Twitter: http://twitter.com/DaveDaDouche
Read my seldom updated blog where I talk to myself: http://davedadouche.blogspot.com/
David Floyd is offline  
Old December 17, 2003, 13:44   #43
Sava
PolyCast Team
Emperor
 
Sava's Avatar
 
Local Time: 09:46
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: Mar 2001
Location: mmmm sweet
Posts: 3,041
Quote:
Originally posted by David Floyd
I oppose the atomic bombings (and the entire war) as much as anybody, but I fail to see how displaying a VERY FAMOUS historical artifact from the war is wrong. It may be insensitive to people who lived through the war, but then again no one forces them to look at it. Personally, I'd definitely go see the Enola Gay - I was disappointed at having missed it at the National Air and Space Museum a few years ago.
I'm not sure it's the display, per se... I think it's the way it is being displayed. I don't oppose displaying the Enola Slowwhand... but it shouldn't glorify the atomic annihilation of 150,000 people, and the thousands that died of radiation poisoning...
__________________
(\__/) "Sava is teh man" -Ecthy
(='.'=)
(")_(") bring me everyone
Sava is offline  
Old December 17, 2003, 13:49   #44
Boris Godunov
Civilization II MultiplayerApolytoners Hall of FameCivilization IV: Multiplayer
Emperor
 
Boris Godunov's Avatar
 
Local Time: 07:46
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: Aug 2001
Location: Portland, OR
Posts: 4,412
Quote:
Originally posted by Sava
I'm not sure it's the display, per se... I think it's the way it is being displayed. I don't oppose displaying the Enola Slowwhand... but it shouldn't glorify the atomic annihilation of 150,000 people, and the thousands that died of radiation poisoning...
I don't see any evidence it does any such thing. What "glorification" is done? It seems to me that it just presents the history sans any value judgment. Not having seen the exhibit, it's easy to criticize.

I agree with DF--I don't like that we dropped the bombs, but I don't think an air and space exhibit devoted to the aircraft (not even the bomb) needs to be a place to discuss the volatile emotional issues of the bombing.
__________________
Tutto nel mondo è burla
Boris Godunov is offline  
Old December 17, 2003, 13:52   #45
Sava
PolyCast Team
Emperor
 
Sava's Avatar
 
Local Time: 09:46
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: Mar 2001
Location: mmmm sweet
Posts: 3,041
Quote:
Originally posted by Boris Godunov


I don't see any evidence it does any such thing. What "glorification" is done? It seems to me that it just presents the history sans any value judgment. Not having seen the exhibit, it's easy to criticize.

I agree with DF--I don't like that we dropped the bombs, but I don't think an air and space exhibit devoted to the aircraft (not even the bomb) needs to be a place to discuss the volatile emotional issues of the bombing.
well that's what I took from the article... I guess I shouldn't believe everything I read.
__________________
(\__/) "Sava is teh man" -Ecthy
(='.'=)
(")_(") bring me everyone
Sava is offline  
Old December 17, 2003, 13:56   #46
Tripledoc
ACDG The Human Hive
Chieftain
 
Local Time: 14:46
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: Jan 2003
Posts: 55
Quote:
Originally posted by lord of the mark
Of course there you have a larger issue - this museum does glorify aviation, and implicitly air power. and as everyone know, airpower since 1943 and for the foreseeable future is an area of American dominance and a key component of American power. Unfortunately no discussion of the morality of strategic bombing is possible in a veil of ignorance from that fact.
I don't think everyone knows that airpower is the key to succes and power. I know that dissenting scholars will argue that the key is people's armies. Always has been and always will be. The reason that airpower get so much attention is that it is profitable for scientists to imply that it is.

No nation has been forced by aireal bombardment of strategic assets to surrender. Only when landforces have occupied the centre have nations surrendered. And not even then in all cases.

The reason the Japanese surrendered was that 75 percent of their fishing fleet was sunk and their oil suppply cut off. They had also used up all their reserves of bauxite, used to make alluminium from.

The nukes were simply icing on the cake.
Tripledoc is offline  
Old December 17, 2003, 13:59   #47
Japher
Emperor
 
Japher's Avatar
 
Local Time: 14:46
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: Jun 2002
Location: Mu Mu Land
Posts: 6,570
Quote:
I don't see any evidence it does any such thing. What "glorification" is done? It seems to me that it just presents the history sans any value judgment. Not having seen the exhibit, it's easy to criticize.


Less we forget... why do ppl always seem to want to sweep the trappings of history under the rug and forget? And get angry when someone reminds them?
__________________
Monkey!!!
Japher is offline  
Old December 17, 2003, 14:02   #48
Tripledoc
ACDG The Human Hive
Chieftain
 
Local Time: 14:46
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: Jan 2003
Posts: 55
From the article.
"The Enola Gay bears a label describing it as the "most sophisticated propeller-driven bomber of World War II".

History sans any value judgment?
Tripledoc is offline  
Old December 17, 2003, 14:02   #49
Q Classic
Emperor
 
Q Classic's Avatar
 
Local Time: 09:46
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: Apr 1999
Location: The cities of Orly and Nowai
Posts: 4,228
i have no problem with the exhibit.

i have no problem with the bombings.

i have a problem with people pretending that japan's rape of nanjing or its brutal occupation of korea somehow makes the civilians blameless, when the country was totally militarized and the civilians themselves were complicit in the behavior of the military.
__________________
B♭3
Q Classic is offline  
Old December 17, 2003, 14:07   #50
Boris Godunov
Civilization II MultiplayerApolytoners Hall of FameCivilization IV: Multiplayer
Emperor
 
Boris Godunov's Avatar
 
Local Time: 07:46
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: Aug 2001
Location: Portland, OR
Posts: 4,412
Quote:
Originally posted by Tripledoc
From the article.
"The Enola Gay bears a label describing it as the "most sophisticated propeller-driven bomber of World War II".

History sans any value judgment?
Value as in moral value.
__________________
Tutto nel mondo è burla
Boris Godunov is offline  
Old December 17, 2003, 14:08   #51
DinoDoc
Civilization II Democracy GameApolytoners Hall of Fame
Deity
 
DinoDoc's Avatar
 
Local Time: 09:46
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: Sep 1999
Location: Underwater no one can hear sharks scream
Posts: 11,096
Quote:
Originally posted by Tripledoc
From the article.
"The Enola Gay bears a label describing it as the "most sophisticated propeller-driven bomber of World War II".

History sans any value judgment?
Does the word sophisticated carry a moral value judgement to you?
DinoDoc is offline  
Old December 17, 2003, 14:09   #52
Boris Godunov
Civilization II MultiplayerApolytoners Hall of FameCivilization IV: Multiplayer
Emperor
 
Boris Godunov's Avatar
 
Local Time: 07:46
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: Aug 2001
Location: Portland, OR
Posts: 4,412
Quote:
Originally posted by Q Cubed
i have a problem with people pretending that japan's rape of nanjing or its brutal occupation of korea somehow makes the civilians blameless, when the country was totally militarized and the civilians themselves were complicit in the behavior of the military.
Yes, I'm sure the thousands of children of Hiroshima and Nagasaki had previously been clapping delightfully over the horrors of Nanjing.
__________________
Tutto nel mondo è burla
Boris Godunov is offline  
Old December 17, 2003, 14:16   #53
Gangerolf
Prince
 
Gangerolf's Avatar
 
Local Time: 15:46
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: May 2001
Location: KULTUR-TERROR
Posts: 958
Quote:
Survivors are disappointed the plane is being displayed with no reference to casualty figures at Hiroshima.
I find this totally reasonable. I mean, the label already states that the plane dropped da bomb. What's wrong with adding the number of people it killed?
__________________
CSPA
Gangerolf is offline  
Old December 17, 2003, 14:23   #54
Japher
Emperor
 
Japher's Avatar
 
Local Time: 14:46
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: Jun 2002
Location: Mu Mu Land
Posts: 6,570
Quote:
What's wrong with adding the number of people it killed?
Because then all the protestors would claim that it is bragging.
__________________
Monkey!!!
Japher is offline  
Old December 17, 2003, 14:26   #55
Gangerolf
Prince
 
Gangerolf's Avatar
 
Local Time: 15:46
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: May 2001
Location: KULTUR-TERROR
Posts: 958
I wouldn't be surprised
__________________
CSPA
Gangerolf is offline  
Old December 17, 2003, 14:27   #56
Q Classic
Emperor
 
Q Classic's Avatar
 
Local Time: 09:46
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: Apr 1999
Location: The cities of Orly and Nowai
Posts: 4,228
Quote:
Yes, I'm sure the thousands of children of Hiroshima and Nagasaki had previously been clapping delightfully over the horrors of Nanjing.
of course they weren't clapping delightfully. they were, however, being taught that treatment of koreans and chinese as less than dirt was as it should be, and that being japanese was like being a god.
__________________
B♭3
Q Classic is offline  
Old December 17, 2003, 14:28   #57
lord of the mark
Deity
 
lord of the mark's Avatar
 
Local Time: 10:46
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: Dec 2000
Location: Virginia
Posts: 11,160
Quote:
Originally posted by Tripledoc


I don't think everyone knows that airpower is the key to succes and power. I know that dissenting scholars will argue that the key is people's armies. Always has been and always will be. The reason that airpower get so much attention is that it is profitable for scientists to imply that it is.

No nation has been forced by aireal bombardment of strategic assets to surrender. Only when landforces have occupied the centre have nations surrendered. And not even then in all cases.

The reason the Japanese surrendered was that 75 percent of their fishing fleet was sunk and their oil suppply cut off. They had also used up all their reserves of bauxite, used to make alluminium from.

The nukes were simply icing on the cake.
you will note that i said "a key component" NOT "the key component"

BTW, how do you think the fishing fleet was destroyed and the oil supply cut off - largely by air power, including carrier borne air power. while subs were partly respobsible, submarine bases were moved closer to japan largely due to the victories of US carriers (and land based tactical aircraft) And of course the the Sub base at Midway was saved by the actions of US carriers.
__________________
"A person cannot approach the divine by reaching beyond the human. To become human, is what this individual person, has been created for.” Martin Buber
lord of the mark is offline  
Old December 17, 2003, 14:29   #58
Winston
Emperor
 
Local Time: 16:46
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: Mar 1999
Posts: 6,291
Gangerolf, I read somewhere that none of the other planes in the exhibit have information on the casualties their service caused, and so the museum would follow that line with the Enola Gay also. They said it was an exhibit focusing solely on the technical and military merits of the various aircrafts.
Winston is offline  
Old December 17, 2003, 14:32   #59
Combat Ingrid
Prince
 
Combat Ingrid's Avatar
 
Local Time: 23:46
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: Nov 2001
Location: Smothered in delicious yellow chemical sludge.
Posts: 782
I get the expression that this exhibit tried to keep morals/bragging/whatever away to avoid stirring up emotion.

If they instead would put up a sign telling about the tragic loss of innocent life, you could expect a couple of millions of Texans going there to protest
__________________
The enemy cannot push a button if you disable his hand.
Combat Ingrid is offline  
Old December 17, 2003, 14:37   #60
Imran Siddiqui
staff
Apolytoners Hall of FameAge of Nations TeamPolyCast Team
 
Imran Siddiqui's Avatar
 
Local Time: 10:46
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: Dec 1969
Location: on the corner of Peachtree and Peachtree
Posts: 30,698
There is nothing tasteless and insensitive here. It is simply showing a historical artifact. IMO, the protest is utterly stupid.
__________________
“I give you a new commandment, that you love one another. Just as I have loved you, you also should love one another. By this everyone will know that you are my disciples, if you have love for one another.”
- John 13:34-35 (NRSV)
Imran Siddiqui is offline  
 

Bookmarks

Thread Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is On

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 10:46.


Design by Vjacheslav Trushkin, color scheme by ColorizeIt!.
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.2
Copyright ©2000 - 2010, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Apolyton Civilization Site | Copyright © The Apolyton Team