Thinkin' out loud....

Velociryx · June 12, 2001, 20:36

Hmm....well, now I'm in the "dead zone" in between rounds of revisions on the guide, and I'm thinking to myself.....you know, self....there's two really cool games coming out soon....HOMM4 and Civ3.....be kinna neat to write strat guides for them as well.....sort of a series, if you will.....

-=Vel=-

Tai Mai Shu · June 12, 2001, 23:48

I'm planning on getting Civ3 when it comes out and I'd definitely love to read another guide by you Vel

Your SMAC guide has been more than helpful and without which I'd still be stuck playing SP on Talent mode instead of Transcend.

Deimos · June 13, 2001, 00:34

Here's a second vote for Civ3, at least as the first of the two. From what I have gathered so far about Civ3, it should be fairly "SMACish" in feel, e.g. they have added a "former" units, improved version of SMAC diplomacy, etc.

Therefore, a Civ3 guide would probably end up borrowing a great deal from the underlying concepts presented in your SMAC guide, and consequently, should be easier to produce. Your publisher (and fans, we are Legion, you know

) would definately appreciate that.

But, on the other hand, you may be looking for a new challange. If HoMM4, as I believe it to be (haven't had an opportunity to play any of the HoMM games), is significantly different in flavor and texture from SMAC, then doing another guide that is similar to your previous cannon may not engage your creative side in the way that you would like.

ln the end, it all boils down to one concept: producing which guide would make you happiest? Your readers will snap up and devour either work.

Rynn: · June 13, 2001, 01:53

Or maybe send Sid M a complimentary copy of the SMAC/X guide and get blessed as the official guide producer for Civ III?

Just a thought

Darkstar · June 13, 2001, 19:01

A very GOOD idea!

Velociryx · June 13, 2001, 21:51

An outstanding idea, Rynn.....I think I'll do just that....

-=Vel=-

bondetamp · June 14, 2001, 18:34

The problem, of course, is whether your civ3 guide will be as good as your current SMAX guide, if it has to hit the stores two weeks after the game release. After all, the SMAX guide is a product of countless discussions and hours of playing (or so I am led to believe, at least).

And what happens if you sign a contract to write a guide, and then it turns out that you simply don't like the game?

The Commodore · June 16, 2001, 20:20

Vel, if you like, I could start a petition thread to send to Jeff and Sid.

Ogie Oglethorpe · June 16, 2001, 21:19

Vel,

Go for it for either strat guide, specially if you can get that Sid guy to ante up and acknowledge the superlative guide master you are. Course you know most folks here are going to have a leaning towards Civ 3, (myself included). But that never stopped me from a good fantasy role play game. Think I'll go fire up a round of Diablo 2 matter fo fact.

Bond makes a good point tho' if the guide is supposed to be rather timely with the release of Civ3 then by the time you have a chance to delve into the complexities of the game the guide will be out a bit late. Perhaps if you contact Sid et.al. you should ask for the opportunity to beta Civ3 in order to get a head start. Hopefully once they see the quality of SMAC guide V3 they'll realize it is intheir best interest.

Og

Solver · June 17, 2001, 08:17

Vel,
Civ 3 guide is a must, but perhaps somebody else wants to write it? Guys are enthusiastic, and want to try themselves as authors.

Jokka das Trevas · June 17, 2001, 15:20

You guys can't forget about Master of Orion 3!

And sorry my ignorance, but what's HOMM3 ?

Velociryx · June 18, 2001, 19:30

Hey guys! Excellent ideas and posts all around! I like the idea of sending a complimentary copy to Sid and Company.....if they like it, perhaps they'd be interested to see what I could come up with for Civ3....if not...::shrug:: Well, I'm not writing it for them....

'bout other folks writing strategy guides: I think it's a great idea! Writing has always been, to me, a rainbow. If I can lay claim to even a single shade in that rainbow, then I'll feel as though I've accomplished something, but there's always plenty of room, and plenty other colors in the rainbow, so I say the more the merrier, where other strat guides are concerned!

And Og! There's a name I haven't seen pop up in a while! How you been, man?!

Would have responded sooner to this and other threads, but strange server problems at work have made it all but impossible to reach the site from there....::sigh::

-=Vel=-