The Value of Critics - Page 2

Libertarian · February 12, 2002, 13:59

Well, we can certainly agree on that.

Harovan · February 12, 2002, 14:12

By the way, this "2 planes" remark of Lib made me think...

To let a plane sink a battleship (or their real representations), would be wrong.

To let a plane not sink a battleship, is also wrong.

So why don't we agree to the rule: If a naval unit is initially down to 1hp and the bombardement succeeds, the unit is destroyed. Similar to the non-retreating of 1hp-injured cavalry units?

Would be a good compromise, I think. Soren, are you still lurking?