View Poll Results: Which civs could be replaced by a worthier civ?
Americans 31 12.81%
Aztecs 13 5.37%
Iroquois 58 23.97%
English 10 4.13%
French 12 4.96%
Germans 10 4.13%
Russians 6 2.48%
Romans 5 2.07%
Greeks 6 2.48%
Egyptians 5 2.07%
Zulus 35 14.46%
Babylonians 12 4.96%
Persians 9 3.72%
Indians 11 4.55%
Japanese 12 4.96%
Chinese 7 2.89%
Multiple Choice Poll. Voters: 242. You may not vote on this poll

 
 
Thread Tools
Old May 3, 2002, 20:45   #151
Jon Shafer
PtWDG RoleplayPtWDG Gathering StormPtWDG Neu DemogypticaInterSite Democracy Game: Apolyton TeamPtWDG LegolandPtWDG Vox ControliPtWDG Glory of WarPtWDG2 SunshineApolyton UniversityC3CDG Desolation RowApolytoners Hall of FameCivilization IV CreatorsC4DG SarantiumApolyCon 06 ParticipantsPtWDG Lux Invicta
Firaxis Games Programmer/Designer
 
Local Time: 19:46
Local Date: October 31, 2010
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: Maryland
Posts: 9,567
Quote:
Originally posted by Boris Godunov
*desperately tries to drag topic back on*

So who's more worthless...the French or the English?

Napoleon owns you!

And so does Germany!
Jon Shafer is offline  
Old May 3, 2002, 20:57   #152
Boris Godunov
Civilization II MultiplayerApolytoners Hall of FameCivilization IV: Multiplayer
Emperor
 
Boris Godunov's Avatar
 
Local Time: 16:46
Local Date: October 31, 2010
Join Date: Aug 2001
Location: Portland, OR
Posts: 4,412
Duh...I forgot one of the most influentual aspects of the Germans.

It was two Germans who formulated a social theory that would change the entire world and touch every corner of the globe.

Karl Marx and Frederich Engels.
__________________
Tutto nel mondo è burla
Boris Godunov is offline  
Old May 3, 2002, 21:33   #153
Jon Shafer
PtWDG RoleplayPtWDG Gathering StormPtWDG Neu DemogypticaInterSite Democracy Game: Apolyton TeamPtWDG LegolandPtWDG Vox ControliPtWDG Glory of WarPtWDG2 SunshineApolyton UniversityC3CDG Desolation RowApolytoners Hall of FameCivilization IV CreatorsC4DG SarantiumApolyCon 06 ParticipantsPtWDG Lux Invicta
Firaxis Games Programmer/Designer
 
Local Time: 19:46
Local Date: October 31, 2010
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: Maryland
Posts: 9,567
Germans also invented: The modern bicycle (Baron Karl von Drais de Sauerbrun), bunsen burner (Robert Wilhelm Bunsen ), blue jeans (Levi Strauss), kindergarden (Friedrich Wilhelm August Fröbel), the first globe (Martin Behaim), the gas powered motorcycle (Gottlieb Daimler), the first x-ray detector (Wilhelm Konrad von Roentgen), the first refracting telescope (Hans Lippershey), and the Richter Scale (Charles Francis Richter), among other things.
Jon Shafer is offline  
Old May 3, 2002, 21:33   #154
SpencerH
Civilization III PBEMCivilization III MultiplayerBtS Tri-League
Emperor
 
SpencerH's Avatar
 
Local Time: 18:46
Local Date: October 31, 2010
Join Date: Feb 2002
Location: Back in BAMA full time.
Posts: 4,502
I think we're arguing with different definitions of culture. So I'll try to explain my point of view.

One way to express this is that a civs culture is an abstract link between the people in that civ. In some cases objects or ideas are metaphors for the culture, but not in all cases.

For example, I dont know whether the Chinese invented chopsticks, but chopsticks are a metaphor for chinese culture to the west. On the other hand Benz invented the automobile (I'll take your word for it) but when people see an automobile they dont think of Germany.

The same concept applies to ideas as well. Marx and Engels have had enormous effect of the world, but if everyone (and I'm not saying they do) believes them to be russian they cant be accounted as part of German culture.

IMO there are more objects and ideas on a world wide scope that are metaphors for chinese culture than there are for German culture. That doesnt mean they are more important, but simply that they are identifiable as belonging to a particular culture (rightly or in some cases wrongly). The polynesians invented surfing, but it is a metaphor of American culture. In this way chinese culture is more world-wide in scope than the Germans.
__________________
We need seperate human-only games for MP/PBEM that dont include the over-simplifications required to have a good AI
If any man be thirsty, let him come unto me and drink. Vampire 7:37
Just one old soldiers opinion. E Tenebris Lux. Pax quaeritur bello.
SpencerH is offline  
Old May 3, 2002, 21:45   #155
Ethelred
King
 
Ethelred's Avatar
 
Local Time: 15:46
Local Date: October 31, 2010
Join Date: Mar 2002
Location: Anaheim, California
Posts: 1,083
Quote:
Originally posted by Trip
Germans also invented: -- blue jeans (Levi Strauss), --
A Californian from Germany invented Jeans. He wouldn't have done that in Germany since they were invented for gold miners.
Ethelred is offline  
Old May 3, 2002, 22:40   #156
Jon Shafer
PtWDG RoleplayPtWDG Gathering StormPtWDG Neu DemogypticaInterSite Democracy Game: Apolyton TeamPtWDG LegolandPtWDG Vox ControliPtWDG Glory of WarPtWDG2 SunshineApolyton UniversityC3CDG Desolation RowApolytoners Hall of FameCivilization IV CreatorsC4DG SarantiumApolyCon 06 ParticipantsPtWDG Lux Invicta
Firaxis Games Programmer/Designer
 
Local Time: 19:46
Local Date: October 31, 2010
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: Maryland
Posts: 9,567
Ahhh, but I said a German invented it, didn't I? I didn't say anything else.
Jon Shafer is offline  
Old May 3, 2002, 23:14   #157
Ethelred
King
 
Ethelred's Avatar
 
Local Time: 15:46
Local Date: October 31, 2010
Join Date: Mar 2002
Location: Anaheim, California
Posts: 1,083
As a Californian I felt it was important to make it "Perfectly clear", to quote another Californian.
Ethelred is offline  
Old May 4, 2002, 00:31   #158
Boris Godunov
Civilization II MultiplayerApolytoners Hall of FameCivilization IV: Multiplayer
Emperor
 
Boris Godunov's Avatar
 
Local Time: 16:46
Local Date: October 31, 2010
Join Date: Aug 2001
Location: Portland, OR
Posts: 4,412
Quote:
Originally posted by SpencerH
I think we're arguing with different definitions of culture. So I'll try to explain my point of view.

One way to express this is that a civs culture is an abstract link between the people in that civ. In some cases objects or ideas are metaphors for the culture, but not in all cases.
I find that definition to be far too susceptible to the vagaries of personal biases and arbitrary whims, but you can define things as you want.

Quote:
For example, I dont know whether the Chinese invented chopsticks, but chopsticks are a metaphor for chinese culture to the west. On the other hand Benz invented the automobile (I'll take your word for it) but when people see an automobile they dont think of Germany.
I know plenty of people when they see a car think of German engineering (and you can look up Benz easily, so don't take my word for it. I hope you're not implying I'd lie to you?) But this again is arbitrarily using, instead of meaningful impact on the world, cultural stereotyping. Chopsticks have done diddly-squat to effect the future of the globe, so to cite them as indicative of cultural influence I think is silly. But to humor you, I think you should see your perspective here as indicative of your immersion within a Eurocentric bias. You are so used to the influences of German culture that you live them as your own and don't think twice about them. But as you are unfamiliar with Chinese culture, the chopsticks are therefore more exotic and stick out in your mind more. But you drink Beer all the time. When I think Beer, I think German. When I see a hotdog (Frankfurter?) or sausage, I think German. Leiderhosen? Now come on, can you *seriously* say German culture hasn't made as much of an impact? Think about it harder.

Quote:
The same concept applies to ideas as well. Marx and Engels have had enormous effect of the world, but if everyone (and I'm not saying they do) believes them to be russian they cant be accounted as part of German culture.
In which case, you should withdraw your mention of gunpowder, silk and porcelain, because I'd wager 99% of people don't think of China when they think of these things.

Quote:
IMO there are more objects and ideas on a world wide scope that are metaphors for chinese culture than there are for German culture.
I think you're quite wrong. See my comment above--you're just so immersed in them that you haven't taken notice. Take a walk into your local Barnes & Noble History section. I'd say we have there a good idea of popular conceptions of what is important. You can just see the number of shelves devoted to German History as opposed to Chinese. A small, perhaps trivial example, but I think one crucial aspect of a culture's impact is how much it generates in such things.

All of this aside (Why you are arguing still about the Chinese I don't know) I REALLY want to get a rational explanation for your baffling choice of the Mongols over the Germans, using your criteria. Aside from Mongolian Beef, they got nuttin!

Quote:
The polynesians invented surfing, but it is a metaphor of American culture. In this way chinese culture is more world-wide in scope than the Germans.
I'd hate to think a large part of what your considering Chinese world-wide culture is based on the racist stereotypes which Westerners have made about Chinese culture, but that seems to be what you are hinting at...

At any rate, I appreciate the explanation, but I don't think such a narrow and arbitrary notion of culture would fly with most anthropologists or sociologists. In addition, it still doesn't rebut the point I've made again and again: For just the past century, German civilization as inexorably and dramatically altered the course of world history and civilization, for better or for worse. I think that alone should be pretty convincing to even the biggest German-haters for German inclusion among the most influential civilizations in the world.
__________________
Tutto nel mondo è burla
Boris Godunov is offline  
Old May 4, 2002, 00:36   #159
Jon Shafer
PtWDG RoleplayPtWDG Gathering StormPtWDG Neu DemogypticaInterSite Democracy Game: Apolyton TeamPtWDG LegolandPtWDG Vox ControliPtWDG Glory of WarPtWDG2 SunshineApolyton UniversityC3CDG Desolation RowApolytoners Hall of FameCivilization IV CreatorsC4DG SarantiumApolyCon 06 ParticipantsPtWDG Lux Invicta
Firaxis Games Programmer/Designer
 
Local Time: 19:46
Local Date: October 31, 2010
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: Maryland
Posts: 9,567
Boris.
Jon Shafer is offline  
Old May 4, 2002, 00:44   #160
siredgar
Prince
 
siredgar's Avatar
 
Local Time: 18:46
Local Date: October 31, 2010
Join Date: Nov 2001
Location: New York, NY
Posts: 543
Chopsticks are an efficient eating utensil and a civilized means of taking food into your mouth. They require a certain degree of dexterity and elegance when used properly. Also, they make you take longer to consume less food. On the other hand, a fork and knife tends to encourage "shoveling" behavior. Worse yet, is just a spoon or your bare hands. Because of this, many American vegetarians use chopsticks even when they don't eat Asian food.
__________________
"I've spent more time posting than playing."
siredgar is offline  
Old May 4, 2002, 00:47   #161
Boris Godunov
Civilization II MultiplayerApolytoners Hall of FameCivilization IV: Multiplayer
Emperor
 
Boris Godunov's Avatar
 
Local Time: 16:46
Local Date: October 31, 2010
Join Date: Aug 2001
Location: Portland, OR
Posts: 4,412
I'm an American vegetarian who is quite adroit with chopsticks, thank you very much.

But which is more important...chopsticks...or beer and pretzels?!

*oompahpah oompahpah*
__________________
Tutto nel mondo è burla
Boris Godunov is offline  
Old May 4, 2002, 08:11   #162
SpencerH
Civilization III PBEMCivilization III MultiplayerBtS Tri-League
Emperor
 
SpencerH's Avatar
 
Local Time: 18:46
Local Date: October 31, 2010
Join Date: Feb 2002
Location: Back in BAMA full time.
Posts: 4,502
Quote:
Originally posted by Boris Godunov

I find that definition to be far too susceptible to the vagaries of personal biases and arbitrary whims, but you can define things as you want.
While you havent provided a definition, it seems clear that like too many Americans you think culture is something that can be quantified (like shiny objects).

Quote:
(and you can look up Benz easily, so don't take my word for it. I hope you're not implying I'd lie to you?)
No I dont think you're lying, but you may be mistaken. You did claim that the Germans invented the sausage.

Quote:
But this again is arbitrarily using, instead of meaningful impact on the world, cultural stereotyping.
Culture doesnt have to have meaningful impact. Do you claim that MacDonalds is not an American cultural icon or that it has meaningful impact?

Quote:
Chopsticks have done diddly-squat to effect the future of the globe, so to cite them as indicative of cultural influence I think is silly. But to humor you, I think you should see your perspective here as indicative of your immersion within a Eurocentric bias. You are so used to the influences of German culture that you live them as your own and don't think twice about them. But as you are unfamiliar with Chinese culture, the chopsticks are therefore more exotic and stick out in your mind more. But you drink Beer all the time. When I think Beer, I think German. When I see a hotdog (Frankfurter?) or sausage, I think German. Leiderhosen? Now come on, can you *seriously* say German culture hasn't made as much of an impact? Think about it harder.
I grew up in a chinese culture so I think its quite likely that I know a great deal more about them from a cultural perspective than you.

Quote:
In which case, you should withdraw your mention of gunpowder, silk and porcelain, because I'd wager 99% of people don't think of China when they think of these things.
You associate an American or Japanese car with Germany but you dont associate gunpowder, silk and porcelain with China

Quote:
I think you're quite wrong. See my comment above--you're just so immersed in them that you haven't taken notice. Take a walk into your local Barnes & Noble History section. I'd say we have there a good idea of popular conceptions of what is important. You can just see the number of shelves devoted to German History as opposed to Chinese. A small, perhaps trivial example, but I think one crucial aspect of a culture's impact is how much it generates in such things.
You are mistaking history for culture. They are not inter-changable although one may have impact on the other.

[QUOTE] All of this aside (Why you are arguing still about the Chinese I don't know) I REALLY want to get a rational explanation for your baffling choice of the Mongols over the Germans, using your criteria. Aside from Mongolian Beef, they got nuttin![QUOTE]

I thought it was pretty clear, but I'll repeat it for you. The criteria that I put forth were civs with world-wide cultural impact and/or world-wide empires. The chinese were included based on culture (that was your original target for "why werent the Germans there". The Mongolians were included beacause of their empire not their culture.

Quote:
At any rate, I appreciate the explanation, but I don't think such a narrow and arbitrary notion of culture would fly with most anthropologists or sociologists. In addition, it still doesn't rebut the point I've made again and again: For just the past century, German civilization as inexorably and dramatically altered the course of world history and civilization, for better or for worse. I think that alone should be pretty convincing to even the biggest German-haters for German inclusion among the most influential civilizations in the world.
No one could claim that Germany hasnt had an impact on the history of the 20 th century. Again you are mistaking culture for history.
__________________
We need seperate human-only games for MP/PBEM that dont include the over-simplifications required to have a good AI
If any man be thirsty, let him come unto me and drink. Vampire 7:37
Just one old soldiers opinion. E Tenebris Lux. Pax quaeritur bello.
SpencerH is offline  
Old May 4, 2002, 09:27   #163
Ribannah
Queen
 
Ribannah's Avatar
 
Local Time: 00:46
Local Date: November 1, 2010
Join Date: Aug 2000
Location: The Netherlands, Embassy of the Iroquois Confederacy
Posts: 1,578
While I'm not about to throw any of them out, at gunpoint I would select the following order of removal:

[1] Zulus (nice spears)
[2] Aztecs (short-lived local bullwhip)
[3] Persia (one of many similar empires, didn't do anything great)

To be replaced with eg Ethiopia, Maya, Arabia.
__________________
A horse! A horse! Mingapulco for a horse! Someone must give chase to Brave Sir Robin and get those missing flags ...
Project Lead of Might and Magic Tribute
Ribannah is offline  
Old May 4, 2002, 09:28   #164
MarkG
Apolytoners Hall of FameApolyCon 06 Participants
Apolyton CS Co-Founder
 
MarkG's Avatar
 
Local Time: 01:46
Local Date: November 1, 2010
Join Date: Aug 1998
Location: Macedonia, Greece
Posts: 24,480
Quote:
No one should be removed from the game, only added.
__________________
Co-Founder, Apolyton Civilization Site
Co-Owner/Webmaster, Top40-Charts.com | CTO, Apogee Information Systems
giannopoulos.info: my non-mobile non-photo news & articles blog
MarkG is offline  
 

Bookmarks

Thread Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is On

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 19:46.


Design by Vjacheslav Trushkin, color scheme by ColorizeIt!.
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.2
Copyright ©2000 - 2010, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Apolyton Civilization Site | Copyright © The Apolyton Team