I'd definitely prefer constructive criticism of my scenarios to no feedback at all, so I don't see what's so bad about this thread.
However some of the scenarios out there are truly awful - look at that Afghanistan one, it doesn't appear as if the author put much work into it all. Afghanistan as an island!
But hey, I'm not going to name anyone in particular myself because I'm a nice guy (I can't think of any outsandingly bad one).
Well, the person making the Afghan scenario could have put in at least a decent effort. I can't tell if it was made by a five-year-old or someone that wanted to play a joke on his friends.
Let me know how my new humor scenario - Battle for the Banana Republic - stacks up with the worst. Is it on the same level of badness with these others?