Pheer me fellow contestants! You stand not a chance! - DarthVeda
With WarVoid inexplicably absent, I have a few thoughts about how we should handle this.
1. Screw codenames. There are no prizes and we all know each other. I don't think anyone will have any doubts as to which of the scenarios is mine anyways.
2. Each of the submissions will be given a stickied thread in the PBEM forum. The same group of volunteers will play each of the scenarios for a reasonable period of time and rank them from best to worst.
We'll either have to have people play multiple sides in the scenarios with the above average number of human civs or alternate in controlling sides in the scenarios with the a below average number of human civs.
3. Concurrently, we'll have a People's Choice poll in this forum. It would probably be best if the people both voted in it and posted with their vote for verification purposes.