Best civ Type Game

necrosmith · March 25, 2003, 21:16

I was just wondering what everyone's thoughts are on which is the best civ-type game?

CTP? Civ2? Civ3? SMAC?

Six Thousand Year Old Man · March 25, 2003, 21:23

Civ2.

But you may get a different answer on the Civ3, CtP, or SMAC forums.

SCG · March 25, 2003, 21:34

have to go with Civ II

btw, might be interested in this thread in the Civilization Games General/Future forum

Ben Kenobi · March 26, 2003, 02:38

Gotta go with Civ 2.

Good link, SCG.

DrSpike · March 26, 2003, 06:03

Civ2 followed by SMAC........though many prefer SMAC. Some even like CTP(2)!

Scouse Gits · March 26, 2003, 06:48

Civ2 of course

SG[1]

Bloody Monk · March 26, 2003, 12:08

Thank you for the opportunity to log +1.

Civ II is the True Game.

Monk

atawa · March 26, 2003, 12:53

Quote:

Originally posted by Bloody Monk
Thank you for the opportunity to log +1.

Civ II is the True Game.

Monk

I agree

Old n Slow · March 26, 2003, 14:12

Ditto for civ II -- but once I open my copies of SMAC & Civ III I might be able to vote civ II with a higher confidence level.

ColdWizard · March 26, 2003, 14:19

definitely civ2, though i've not tried ctp or ctp2

Gatekeeper · March 26, 2003, 17:38

Civ II, hands down.

Kaptain Ken · March 27, 2003, 13:54

Civ II, closely followed by SMAX.
Moo2 is a great 4X game, like Civ 2, it is better than 3.
Railroad Tycoon 2 is also fun if you are a builder.

Straybow · March 27, 2003, 15:23

CIV2!!

I find the others (I've played almost all of 'em) get tedious.

La Fayette · March 28, 2003, 11:12

IMHO civ2 is not the best civ type game

CIV2 IS THE BEST GAME (any kind of game)

one more turn, please!

I'm fairly sure that I have spent more time playing civ2 than all other games put together

Kaptain Ken · April 2, 2003, 17:43

TOT is best for scenario design, MPG for having the most scenarios to play, and SMAC(X) for having the most depth and best story. I too have spent more time with all the versions of Civ than all other games combined.

Hydey · April 2, 2003, 18:28

Civ 2 is the best all round game, after about 500 games the others become a little stall but civ2 still has that one more turn feel.

Old n Slow · April 3, 2003, 11:31

Quote:

Originally posted by La Fayette

I'm fairly sure that I have spent more time playing civ2 than all other games put together

Oh I think I still have a ways to go -- I think I logged over 700 games of Strategic Conquest, at about 6 hours per game average. It’s a search the world, found cities, conquer the ai game…no wonder I liked it (didn’t have civ at that time).

Bloody Monk · April 3, 2003, 13:09

Before I discovered Civ, I too spent many hours playing Strategic Conquest. It was on my first computer, a hand me down from my son.

It was a great game for its time and prepped me for Civ. Had many of the same layered logistics and planning aspects. Unfortunately, I no longer have the game. But, really, where would the time come from to play it now that I am so completely addicted to CivII.

The memories are sweet, though. Thanks for bringing it up.

Monk

Bob_Smurf42 · April 3, 2003, 15:10

I can't honestly say I've played the other ones, so i'll have to go with Civ2

and Civ1 at a close second.
From what I've seen of Civ3, it seems too complicated for my liking.

DrSpike · April 3, 2003, 15:41

I'd say civ3 was simpler than civ2.

Paradox · April 4, 2003, 22:39

I bought CTP last year and thoroughly enjoyed it...for quite a while...and still do...in many ways its so like CIV II...in fact im hard pressed right now after playing CIV II to really compare or make a favourite because in so many ways ( exlcuding perhaps trade and diplomacy ) they are similar.....i.e scenario and AI modding,etc.

For me the power in a game is to explore its possibilities and weaknesses, learn how its designed and how the AI gameplay is shaped...then try and find or modify a realistic as possible (and reasonable) setting so the game becomes as real life playing against a computer!!

Perhaps ill progress to MP or PBEM one day but for now
im happy to run at 1 bit per second and beat a 700MHZ brain!!!!!!

Carolus Rex · April 5, 2003, 14:29

There can be only one and it's not Highlander... Civ II!

But I also like MOO2, although I have not played it nearly as much as Civ II.

Carolus

Wazell · April 7, 2003, 12:08

Civ 2 is easily the best, though I have to admit that I play mostly Civ 3 nowadays, and some SMAC.

rah · April 7, 2003, 16:05

I see no bias here

CIV II MP is the best.

Bob_Smurf42 · April 7, 2003, 20:13

Quote:

Originally posted by rah
I see no bias here

Of course not, not in the Civ2 Forum!

I have to say I liked the pedia style of plain Civ2 better,(get_info.exe) but overall, MGE is better, as it has pictures next to the names.

CapTVK · April 8, 2003, 14:07

The 1st place in this case would have to go Civ2MP. Thanks to it excellent collection of scenarios. IMO Freeciv comes in 2nd because of its excellent MP and micromanagment features (which truly come apparent after starting to play regular sessions). The lack of diplomacy in SP (we'll have to wait for 1.15) puts it out of reach for 1st place (for now). Civ3 looks and sounds very good but just doesn't have "it", so 3th place and even then it has to fight for that position with the original Civ1.

I've never gotten into SMAC, "it just ain't earth..." so I'll leave that out of my Top3.