Hopefully one of the last polls...

[Maniac]

There always is something which interferes and prevents us from starting this game... Now there is the discussion whether or not we should grant the request for a fifth human-controlled faction. And that discussion really needs to be finished before starting private fora. I mean, if you were MarkG, would you like it if some dude asked you to create four private fora, and a few days later asked for another one? The same counts for the CMN. He needs to know how many human factions there will be, to create a balanced map. Therefore this hopefully last poll: Should there be a fifth human-played faction of Buster and Triped? Only two days time to vote.

Btw, Buster or Triped, if you read this, could you please tell us asap which faction you'd want to play?

[Maniac]

Ah yes, the discussion thread.

[Method]

alright then, i'll hold off on PMing markos about private forums and civgroups until this poll has ended

[Static Universe]

I vote yes. Granted it will make the game slightly slower, but I think it will be more interesting overall (not that it wouldn't be interesting with only 4 ).

[Maniac]

alright then, i'll hold off on PMing markos about private forums and civgroups until this poll has ended

Oh ok. Btw, I didn't mean you when I said "dude". Since I will be looking for a CMN (I am currently writing a PM to Googlie), I assumed I also would PM MarkG about the private fora, so I was calling myself a dude.

[Method]

whatever, i didn't even see that part. i just skim through most posts anyway

[Micha]

I vote yes.

Hopefully this will result in a clear decision, I can´t bear to wait any longer!!!

[Method]

if there's a more or less clear majority by tomorrow, i'm sending the PM. i can't bear to wait any longer either

[Maniac]

I sent this PM to Googlie. Is it ok?

Hi Googlie,

Recently a group of people, which I am part of, finished our first SMAC democracy game. We enjoyed it and immediately started planning another one. However this time we wanted to do it somewhat differently. Following the example of the Civ3 PtW demo game, we wanted a PBEM ACDG this time. The usual polls for the settings and rules followed. One of these polls dealt with the map we would use. There a majority decided an expert CMN should give us a surprise. Hearing the words "expert CMN" I of course immediately thought of you again. Therefore I'm wondering: could you please be the CMN of our next ACDG?

In case you would, here you can find a summary of several things: that we will be playing a PBEM SMAX Transcend game, using these and these rules, while allowing these bugs/features.

On the subject of the participating factions, things are a bit less clear. We are already sure we want the University of Planet, the Hive, the Consciousness and the Pirates to participate as humans. But now there is discussion and a poll whether we should allow a fifth human-played faction of Buster & Triped, who would join this game as somewhat normal PBEM'ers, giving the demo game teams better opposition. As who would be the two (or three, depending on the poll results) AI factions, that people want to leave up to the "expert CMN" to decide, as a surprise.

Last but not least, there's the map poll, where people decided they want a large map (if you take the mean of all voters) and where there's more or less a tie between 50-70% ocean (to make the map livable for the Pirate faction) and "Let the CMN use his good judgement." On all other points, there's a clear majority for "Let the CMN use his good judgement."

If you would be interested in being the CMN for this pbem acdg, please PM me or pay a visit to the ACDG forum.

Greetings,

Maniac

if there's a more or less clear majority by tomorrow, i'm sending the PM.

Great. Unless of course there's a majority in favour but we still don't know the faction Buster & Triped will use, and there isn't a faction logo for them.

[Nubclear]

Accidently voted YES. Please change my vote to NO.

[Drogue]

Looks good Maniac. I voted no, because I want to keep it simple, and want it to go all the way, thus am playing it safe. However I am not too strong a no, if that makes sense

[Micha]

I´d say if it comes to a putt, we will play with 4 players as it was decided before.

Agreed?

[Drogue]

I agree. Needs a majority to change.

[FlameFlash]

Heh... with Tass' vote it's tied...

Edit: Nevermind... there were more votes right after I posted...

[Nubclear]

My biggest fear is that there will only be two people on their team......And they'll fall QUICKLY.

[Hercules]

I voted yes. I think once it is approved Buster and Triped will recruit more players so it won't be just two.

What I want is another pirate or two or three.

[Hercules]

Excellent Pm to Googlie btw.

Also we still will have a central general forum won't we.

[Googlie]

I'd be happy to set up the game - I've read through all the links and can get started on the map while we wait for the fifth faction resolution

Googlie

[FlameFlash]

Originally posted by Hercules
Also we still will have a central general forum won't we.

Of course! How else are we supposed to recruit?

[Method]

ok! there seems to be a clear majority here to allow buster and triped to play. i'll send markos the PM as soon as i get confirmation on their faction (unless the posted it somewhere i didn't see)

[Jamski]

We'll need a drones (or whatever) icon too - don't forget - dude

-Jam

[Method]

we have it already